> Sports  > Hoopsvibe

 Back to NBA Articles     
  | PDF version
 The NBA 8217 s Top Point Guards 5-1
 


 
C.Y. EllisWritten by: C.Y. Ellis - A basketball fanatic who has followed and played the game for over half his life, Chuck’s tenure at HoopsVibe has seen him cover everything from the NBA to the And1 Mixtape Tour, interviewing (...) More  
 
NBA Articles (most popular)









The NBA’s Top Point Guards, 5-1

  By C.Y. Ellis
01.4.2008 - Updated on 04.26.2008

[Certain of the readers out there - and I use the term "readers" loosely - have emailed me or commented to complain that some of the players listed here are ranked ahead of better point guards. Just to repeat what was stated clearly before, these are not point guard rankings. These are overall player rankings, and the players in question just so happen to be point guards. If Dwight Howard were listed as a one, he’d make the list for the fact that he’s a great player regardless of his abilities as a point. Capiche?]

Those of you who missed the first part of this list should hit that up for an outline of my ranking methodology before reading further. It should save the AOL users amongst you however much time it takes to tape down your Caps Lock key and let loose your stream of pubescent fury.

Anyway, let’s get right into it.

The NBA’s Top Ten Point Guards, Part II


5. Gilbert Arenas
Once again, I open with a pick that many of you will consider as well-reasoned as Stephen Jackson’s decision to play chicken with a truck and lick a few in the air. Still, given that I’ve wiped the injury slate clean for the sake of this list, I can’t imagine anyone being able to make a sensible case for denying Zero Hero a home in the ten. While not one to conform to the traditional expectations of a point guard, Gil solidified his superstar status in ’06-‘07, humiliating defenders the league over with an array of crippling crossovers, meandering dribble-drives and buzzer-beating triples that would look unlikely in a videogame. Although it’s a common criticism that Hibachi has yet to prove his playoff mettle, it’s still tough to overlook the twenty-eight and six dimes he was worth prior to his injury, and those numbers alone were enough to convince me he belonged here. If you could add a little experience and subtract the fact that he’s been the nuttiest S.O.B. on earth since James Brown got (six feet) down, you’d have a player most would consider worthy of a top-three ranking.

4. Baron Davis
What the Warriors did to Dallas last year was downright dirty, and the primary perpetrator of that filth was none other than Boom Dizzle himself. Forever finding new ways to unite leather and nylon, Baron’s unique blend of bulk and bounce means he’s as likely to power through defenders as he is to jump over them. A true 3-D threat, he finds his points on driving dunks, deep threes and everything in between, leaving opponents to pick their poison by either sagging off and watching him hoist the long ball or giving him the lane and exposing their big men to the threat of a facial. While one of the league’s most capable and creative scorers, he’s not scared to share, spreading the love to the tune of eight assists a night. Were it not for the latent menace of the back and knee injuries that have limited his appearances throughout his career, B. Diddy would find himself even further up my rankings.


3. Allen Iverson
What can I say about Allen Iverson that you don’t already know? Only this: At the ripe old age of thirty-two, he’s better than he’s ever been. While most will bring up the names of Wilt Chamberlain and Shaquille O’Neal when discussing the league’s greatest physical anomalies, I’m inclined to mention A.I., a 5’10’’ (don’t believe the listings), 160-pound man who, after eleven years’ experience and enough injuries to retire most players thrice over, remains one of the quickest players on the planet. Although his numbers have dipped a little since joining fellow scorer ‘Melo, he’s still a danger to defences everywhere the second he sets foot on the court, having the ability to drop thirty or dish ten seemingly at will. What’s more, with some of the quickest hands in the league, he’s pesky at both ends of the floor and, though not known as a lock-down defender, still ranks among the league leaders in steals every year.


2. Steve Nash
Oh, how I hate myself already for this one. Still, to make a decision as ostensibly dickwitted as to propose that the two-time league MVP is outclassed at the position he has come to define, I must have a fantastic statistical justification, right? Would that it were, folks. You see, while Nashty’s numbers (17 and 12 on .508 FG%, .459 3P% and .904 FT%) are unparalleled, I’m inclined to look not so much at the Suns as the Mavericks when discussing Canada’s favourite son. While he certainly took Phoenix to new heights as the orchestrator of one of the most efficient run-and-gun offences of the modern era, you can’t forget that the team he left didn’t take long to make it to the finals without him. Although it would be a stretch to say that he’s only worth his salt in the Grand Canyon State, it’s reasonable to suggest that, at thirty years old, his rise from top-tier guard to MVP winner was more to do with a change of scenery than an improvement in his game. Nonetheless, Steve will retire as one of the greatest shooters, passers and team leaders of his generation, and were it not for the once-in-a-lifetime talent ahead of him, he would have been a lock for the top spot this season as in years past.


1. Chris Paul
Why, then, does CP3 take the top spot ahead of the taller, tougher, more experienced, more accomplished Steve Nash? Simple: While Nash’s tenure in Phoenix has seen him benefit from a tailor-made milieu, Chris Paul is balling out of his mind in a mediocre situation. So, while he may be averaging ten assists to Steve’s twelve, you’d better believe Paul would find another pair of dimes a night with the Sun’s three-headed monster of a front line filling the lanes in place of David West, Peja Stojakovic and Tyson Chandler. He’s also found a way to get his while moving the rock, averaging 21.3 on the season, a four-point increase on last year’s production which has been accompanied by improvements in his field-goal, three-point and free-throw percentages. Furthermore, with a league-leading 2.9 thefts per, he’s not exactly dead weight at the other end of the floor, putting his unusual foot speed and cat-quick reflexes to good use. In Paul, the Hornets have a world-class basketball talent whose proven ability to turn nothing into something makes him, to my mind, your best bet at the point guard position.



Questions? Comments? Death threats? Get at me via email (cyellis@gmail.com), the forum (HoopsVibe.com/forum) or the comment box below. Keep your eyes open for the first half of my countdown of the top ten swingmen, which should be appearing in the next day or two.

- CYE

23 Comments: The NBA’s Top Point Guards, 5-1

Posted by

on 04.26.2008
jason kidd honorable mention? uh...maybe check the 10-6 article douche. and for the last comment - 1. iverson has played more point than shooting guard this year. 2. check the date on the article idiot. it was written way before gil got hurt. damn some people are stupid. .
Posted by

on 04.26.2008
I agree with this, but am wondering why JKidd isn’t in the top 5. D.Williams makes a strong case too. And last time I checked Iverson is a shooting guard and Arenas didn’t even play this year. .
Posted by
brandon
on 03.18.2008
i believe kobe is the best in the nba beacuse just look how spectular he is. .
Posted by
josh johnson
on 01.21.2008
i read the list and i was like wow what a great list but then i felt like something was missing took me a couple minutes but i finally got it..where is jason kidd is on this list not even honoroable mention thats tough.deron williams should be HM too..Kidd over iverson is great argument. .
Posted by
Necron101
on 01.9.2008
I find it really hard to believe that Christ Paul is already the #1 PG in the league. If you want to talk about potential for the future, he’s right in there. But if you’re talking about potential, then why don’t you have Derron Williams in there too? .
Posted by

on 01.7.2008
Just glad to see that...Steve "The Human Fart" Trash isn’t number one. I don’t think he should have made the top 10 at all. Just look at his name! .
Posted by
8 Cents
on 01.6.2008
A.I. Nash, Paul, Kidd, WIlliams, Billups, Arenas, Davis, than I don’t even care after that .
Posted by
monikore
on 01.6.2008
1. steve nash- 2 MVPs2. J-kidd- 90+ tds3.a.i.-legend4.hibachi-great scorer & passer5. b diddy-really good can bounce back from xtreme injuries5a. CP3 next nash5.b deron williams-future kidd .
Posted by
crossover2014
on 01.5.2008
To the person who said that getting 10 10 10 ain’t that impressive. You are a f-----idiot a triple double is not that impressive huh? A 6 4 point guard getting more rebounds then most 7 footers not impressive? 96 triple doubles not that impressive? NOT A SPECIAL PASSER? You’ve got to be f-----kidding me. When you start dropping 10 10 and 10 almost nightly then you can talk until then please keep your mouth shut. J-Kidd #1 point in the world. .
Posted by

on 01.5.2008
a great ’player’ is one that makes the people around him better...in that sense, i really don’t see how iverson has done a better job than jkidd...iverson is just a better scoring guard, not a better player...and how can you put arenas up here? he hasnt played all season!!! and he was horrific when he DID play...CMON MAN...but cp3 is totally the number 1 pg/player out there rite now...nash is good, but he really doesnt play defense at all... .
Posted by

on 01.5.2008
im glad kidd isnt in the 5 he gets hardly a triple double 10 10 10 every here in there aint that impressive he cant score for nothing and hes no longer that special of a passer n i guess hes a decent rebounder for a pg im just glad hes not in the top 5 .
Posted by

on 01.5.2008
skill wise cp3 is the worst one out of the 5 i say and ai or baron is in the one spot then gil then nash but yous must be listing as pgs not players .
Posted by
wal
on 01.5.2008
j kidd hands down number one point guard in the league .
Posted by
A.D
on 01.5.2008
Chris Paul is not better than Nash or Allen Iverson. Maybe in the feature but not now. He is barely better than Baron Davis. And J Kidd should be in tha top 5 .
Posted by
Deannba
on 01.5.2008
YESS !!! Nash isnt number one !!! Jason Kidds still the better player and deserves too be in the top 5, i knw you did it as best players not best point guards but the only reason Kidds not there is his scoring right ? Because every other state is as good or better when compared too the other guys in the top 5 ! .
Posted by
C.Y. Ellis
on 01.5.2008
I don’t know how it’s possible, but evidently some of you are capable of writing but not reading. I’ll say this one last time for the benefit of our special friends: I am not ranking these players as point guards. They’re ranked based on their overall ability, and the only reason the words "point guard" appear is because I’ve split the league’s players into point guards, swingmen and big men for the sake of these rankings. Just to repeat, they’re ranked as players, not as point guards. .
Posted by
THE UNDERTAKER
on 01.5.2008
IF IT’S MY TOP 5...I’LL GO BY THEIR CAREER PLAY...NOT BY WHO’S PLAYING BETTER THAN WHO THAT SEASON AND I’LL GO BY THE TRUE DEFINITION OF POINT GUARD SO MY LIST WILL BE.... #1 JASON KIDD, #2 STEVE NASH, #3 BARON DAVIS, #4 CHRIS PAUL & #5 JAMAL TINSLEY) .
Posted by
C.Y. Ellis
on 01.5.2008
Once again, I’m rating point guards as players, not players as point guards. Kidd and Nash might be the best pure points of the bunch, but that doesn’t necessarily mean they’re the best players. .
Posted by
energy971
on 01.5.2008
I think kidd is better than arenas as a point guard though ! .
Posted by

on 01.5.2008
id swap arenas to 3, ai to 4, and bd to 6, putting kidd at 5, but it looks good. .
  1    2   Next >  

Post your comment:

No profanity or inaproppriate remarks. All i.p. addresses will be saved and abuse/hate posts will be reported to providers and authorities as part of the anti-spam act of 2003, thank you for posting comments on the articles only.
Any message or comment?

Who are you? (optional)




Home
Basketball Forum
NBA News
NBA Features
Resources
Contact Us